nightcrawler
BAN USERAssumptions: G1 and G2 are gatekeepers (not assuming which standing to heaven or hell, this is to find)
Ask following question to G1
"Given that G2 is the Hell gatekeeper but he is saying G1 is the Hell gatekeeper, is G2 lying?"
this above statement will only be a valid statement, if it considers the mutually exclusive Truthness personality of G1 and G2
Above question can be split into two sub statements
1. Given that G2 is the Hell gatekeeper
2. but he(G2) is saying G1 is the Hell gatekeeper
So if we suppose that statement 1 is True, then statement 2 must be a False
Suppose G2 is the Hell gatekeeper :: our supposition
If G1 says: "Yes G2 is lying, I'm heaven gatekeeper" then:
Question is a valid statement and so this means G1 is speaking the truth and G1 is the heaven gatekeeper
If G1 says: "G2 is speaking the truth" then:
Question becomes invalid as G1 answer goes against the mutually exclusivity
so above supposition goes wrong that G2 is the Hell gatekeeper so G2 is the Heaven gatekeeper
and so G1 is a lier and he's the Hell gatekeeper
Errata in Above answer by me.
- nightcrawler August 12, 2015Assumptions: G1 and G2 are gatekeepers (not assuming which standing to heaven or hell, this is to find)
Ask following question to G1
"Given that G2 is the Hell gatekeeper but he is saying G1 is the Hell gatekeeper, is G2 lying?"
this above statement will only be a valid statement, if it considers the mutually exclusive Truthness personality of G1 and G2
Above question can be split into two sub statements
1. Given that G2 is the Hell gatekeeper
2. but he(G2) is saying G1 is the Hell gatekeeper
So if we suppose that statement 1 is True, then statement 2 must be a False
Suppose G2 is the Hell gatekeeper :: our supposition
If G1 says: "Yes G2 is lying, I'm heaven gatekeeper" then:
Question is a valid statement and so this means G1 is speaking the truth and G1 is the heaven gatekeeper
If G1 says: "G2 is speaking the truth" then:
Question becomes invalid as G1 answer goes against the mutually exclusivity
so above supposition goes wrong that G2 is the Hell gatekeeper so G2 is the Heaven gatekeeper
and so G1 is a lier and he's the Hell gatekeeper